Tuesday, September 21, 2010

Final Diptychs








2 comments:

  1. This is sort of a difficult way to comment, but oh well.
    First of all, as I've said before, your scan-o-grams alone are beautiful. I saw you making them, and I am so surprised that the items you selected made such strong images. I think you had a real eye for that part of the assignment, and I hope you work more with scan-o-grams at some point.
    The images alone are also strong, but I do not find myself quite as drawn to them as I do to the scan-o-grams.

    Now specifically to each diptych:
    As I have said before, I think that the first image is your best. The diptych and the photo work together really well. The diptych enhances the photo (which is what I think it should do), and helps to highlight the blue in the image, that otherwise might not be as noticeable.

    For the second image: while I understand what you are trying to do, I find the disharmony to be a little distracting. I did not immediately pick up on the relationship between the scan-o-gram and the image. Both the image and the scan-o-gram are interesting images (in their own ways), but together they don't click as well as the first.

    The third image is probably your most literal interpretation of the diptych idea. I like the contrast between the depth of the scan-o-gram and the shallow nature of the image. While the two work together very well, the pairing is not quite as striking as the first diptych.

    The final image, the one you re-worked, now functions quite well as a single image. I think it was clever to mimic the shape of the arm in the lace; and I like the way the lace is an inverse of the arm, as opposed to a copy. The color of the images match perfectly, and the sparkle of the glitter plays off the sort of glow of the skin from the lighting (I don't know if that was intentional, but it works!) The intensity of the colors match as well (which is one think that I thought was missing before). Overall, a less exciting scan-o-gram, but definitely a better overall image!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I still stand by what I said about the scan-o-grams, and I think everyone pretty much agreed. Please explore more with these because I think you could do some great things! I'm not sure I agreed with the discussion over layering, I think that it draws the images together nicely, especially for that one I think that layout is much more important than I initially imagined, and the reactions people had towards layout questions was really interesting and surprisingly central to the discussion of the photos.

    ReplyDelete