Sunday, September 26, 2010

Blog Theme IV: Too True

Joel Sternfield, from "Stranger Passing"

 A Tourist at the South Street Seaport, New York, New York, July 1987


A Man Responding to a Dare, Port Angeles, Washington, August 2000

What is "suspicious" to me about these photographs are the circumstances under which they were taken. In the top photograph, the woman matchs perfectly with her surroundings, right down to her underwear- which you can see in the photo. It seems odd that she would agree to be photographed with such a clothing malfunction (and she is clearly aware of it, as there is a safety pin holding her skirt together). As for the second photo, Sternfeld would have had to have been so lucky to catch this man, who is responding to a dare and is therefore most likely doing it on short notice, in a photograph.


Francesca Woodman

Untitled New York, 1979-80 

Untitled Providence, Rhode Island, 1975-78

For the most part, Woodman's photographs are very experimental, but in some cases, they verge on being otherworldly. The situations that these subjects are in seem unlikely, yet there is something in their expressions that continues to suggest truth.


Abigail Heyman, from "Dreams and Schemes: Love and Marriage in Modern Times" (1987)




Moments such as these, with a photographer leaning through a window while a man in sunglasses (inside) gives a toast, and a mismatched couple smoking cigarettes presumably soon after their nuptials, seem almost too candid to have been caught as such on camera. The awareness of the taking of photos exists in the top photo (there is a camera in the photo, after all), yet no one seems to acknowledge the photographer.


Nan Goldin, from "I'll Be Your Mirror" (1996)




The idea of permission arises in these photographs. Of course, Goldin did photograph her friends, but how many people would allow themselves to be photographed while dyeing their eyebrows? Posed or not, the subjects of the photographs seem very comfortable, which lends certain credibiltiy to the photographs, but at the same time, their situations seem almost unbelievable. 


Nicolas Nixon, from "Pictures of People" (1988)

 Carson Beach, South Boston, 1978

Cincinnati, 1980.

The lack of awareness on the part of the woman in the first photograph is actually quite funny, but seems almost like an Henri Cartier-Bresson moment- just before the realization. Of course, the woman might not notice, or care, but those possibilities seem even less true. The second photograph is strange to me because I am not sure what I am supposed to think; is this a family? And if so, who is the man in the background the father to? There is just such a range of emotions in the image that I don't know how to think about it, and therefore its level of truth is called into question.

1 comment:

  1. you choices here walk a fine line. Heyman is really more concerned with reportage rather than raising the viewer's consciousness about common notions of the "real" and one could say the same about early Goldin - but her later work starts to be more complex and self-conscious in how the photos are constructed - more formal, more intentional - and less overtly snaps. Nixon, Sternfeld and Woodman are spot on for this BT.

    ReplyDelete